Toyota Highlander Review (US): falls into 'appliance' territory

The Toyota Highlander is a versatile crossover offered in both traditional combustion and hybrid variants. It features a spacious second row and an intuitive array of gadgets, making it a practical choice for families. The standard model is equipped with a 2.4-liter turbocharged engine providing 265 horsepower, while the hybrid utilizes a 2.5-liter engine combined with electric motors, resulting in a total output of 243 horsepower. Despite its capable performance, particularly in hybrid form, the Highlander falls short in terms of excitement and character compared to its sibling, the RAV4, which offers a more appealing price point and personality. The Highlander’s design does not position it as a standout option, sitting in the middle of a saturated Toyota lineup filled with distinctly characterized models like the rugged 4Runner and the versatile RAV4. Its third row is criticized for being cramped, making it more suitable for additional cargo rather than adult passengers. Tech and safety features are adequate, promoting a reasonable level of peace of mind for potential buyers. However, alternatives from competitors like the Hyundai Santa Fe, Honda Pilot, and Kia Telluride offer more space and stylistic flair for a similar price point. Expert opinion highlights that while the Highlander serves well as a family-oriented vehicle, competing models may provide better value propositions. The Highlander is a solid choice if brand loyalty to Toyota is a priority, but for those focused on maximizing space and features, exploring options like the Toyota RAV4 or competitors could lead to a more fulfilling ownership experience. Ultimately, the Highlander excels in practicality but struggles to differentiate itself in a crowded market, earning a reputation as an “appliance” rather than an inspiring vehicle choice.